Jalna: The Andhra Pradesh High Court has ruled that when a minority educational institution selects a candidate from its own minority community, the social reservation roster does not apply. According to a press note issued by Jalna senior advocate Mahesh Dhannawat, the court set aside the education department’s decision to deny approval to the appointment of an attender at a Christian minority school run by the Church of South India (CSI).
Jalna is a district in Maharashtra’s Marathwada region, about 400 km east of Mumbai. Mr Dhannawat, a lawyer based there, has described the verdict as significant for minority institutions across India, including Maharashtra.
What the case was about
M. Rajasekhar, from the Christian minority community, was selected as an attender against a regular, aided vacancy at a CSI high school. The District Education Officer repeatedly refused to approve the appointment, citing three reasons: the post was reserved for the “BC-A (Women)” category, the school had not followed the reservation roster, and no official advertisement had been published in a newspaper.
Mr Rajasekhar challenged the refusal in the High Court through Writ Petition No. 24719/2024. A single-judge bench of Justice Balaji Medamalli delivered the verdict. Noting that the employee had served without interruption for 26 years, the court directed that his service be regularised within four months.
Court’s key observations
Citing Rule 12(6) of the Government Order (GO) dated 1 January 1994, the court observed:
- Minority educational institutions are expressly exempt from reservation rules when they select an eligible candidate from their own minority community.
- The petitioner belongs to the Christian minority and was appointed in a Christian minority institution, so the appointment cannot be rejected for not following the “BC-A (Women)” roster.
- Notice of the vacancy was circulated through local churches and minority institutions instead of a newspaper advertisement. Given this minor technical lapse and the employee’s 26 years of service, the appointment cannot be declared invalid. After taking work from him for 26 years, the administration cannot deny him the benefit of approval.
Advocate Dhannawat’s reaction
Mr Dhannawat said: “This verdict of the Andhra Pradesh High Court is most welcome and protects the constitutional rights of minority educational institutions. Under Article 30 of the Constitution, minorities have a fundamental right to establish and administer their institutions. Often, administrative officials use the roster and technical rules to create unnecessary hurdles in recruitment and in approval of employees at minority schools. This decision makes it clear that institutions cannot be compelled to follow the reservation roster while recruiting candidates from their own community.”
He added that the verdict is not limited to Andhra Pradesh and will be a strong support for minority institutions across the country, including Maharashtra, and for employees who have worked there for years, in securing their legal rights.
Key points
- Minority institutions are exempt from the reservation roster for own-community hires.
- The District Education Officer’s refusal to approve the appointment was set aside.
- The attender, in service for 26 years, is to be regularised within four months.
- Not advertising in a newspaper was treated as a minor technical lapse.
- Justice Balaji Medamalli decided Writ Petition No. 24719/2024.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which court gave the ruling?
A single-judge bench of Justice Balaji Medamalli of the Andhra Pradesh High Court, in Writ Petition No. 24719/2024.
Does the roster exemption apply to all hires?
Per the court’s reading of Rule 12(6) of the 1994 GO, the exemption applies when a minority institution selects an eligible candidate from its own minority community.
What relief did the employee get?
The court ordered that his service be regularised within four months.
Read this story in Hindi: अल्पसंख्यक संस्थाओं को राहत: अपने समाज की भर्ती में रोस्टर जरूरी नहीं
Also read:
➤ Barbie Rewind Brings 16 Classic Games and DreamHouse Design to Modern Platforms
➤ GOG’s First Showcase Brings Classic Game Restorations, Linux Support and a New Publishing Partnership
➤ Saudi Arabia Tourist Visa Guide 2026: Eligibility, eVisa Rules and Travel Checklist
सीधे अपनी Facebook फ़ीड में पाएँ — News Nation Online पेज को Follow करें।
Discover more from NewsNation Online
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.













Leave a Reply