Lucknow: The Allahabad High Court has pulled up the police for keeping four people in illegal detention for ten days at the Gauri Bazar police station in Deoria district. A bench of Justice Atul Sreedharan and Justice Divesh Chandra Samant ordered total compensation of ₹65,000 to the four petitioners and directed that the entire amount be recovered from the salary of the station house officer (SHO), the officer in charge of the police station.
Deoria is a district in Uttar Pradesh, India’s most populous state, and the Allahabad High Court is the state’s high court. According to a press note issued by Adv. Mahesh Dhannawat, a lawyer from Jalna in Maharashtra, the court also described the police as a “bunch of liars” after they claimed that the station’s CCTV cameras were not working and the footage was missing.
CCTV excuse rejected
The case reached the High Court through a habeas corpus petition, a legal remedy that asks a court to examine whether a person is being lawfully held. The petition alleged that four people had been illegally confined at the Gauri Bazar police station. To verify the claims, the court ordered the police to produce CCTV footage from the station.
Also read: Republican Sena marks 28th foundation day in Jalna before a large crowd
The police claimed the CCTV system had developed a technical fault earlier. According to the press note, the court treated this as a cover story and reprimanded the district Superintendent of Police and the SHO, who appeared in person. When it emerged that there was no entry about any CCTV fault or repair in the station’s general diary, the court remarked that an SHO who cannot make a simple diary entry is not fit to hold the post and should be dismissed outright.
The court rejected the apology offered by the Superintendent of Police, telling him to apologise to the public rather than to the court. It also criticised the department for merely transferring the SHO to the crime branch instead of taking firm action. The bench raised strong objections over the use of ₹46.46 lakh sanctioned by the government for CCTV and the poor condition of the system.
“An old habit of the police”: Adv. Mahesh Dhannawat
Reacting to the order, Adv. Mahesh Dhannawat, former vice-president of the Jalna District Bar Association, said: “In the Paramvir Singh Saini case, the Supreme Court made it mandatory to install CCTV cameras with night vision and audio-video recording in every police station in the country. This order was given to protect citizens’ fundamental rights. But whenever custodial assault or illegal arrest takes place, giving the flimsy excuse that ‘the CCTV was off’ has become an old habit of the police.”
He added: “In such cases, the Allahabad High Court’s order to recover compensation directly from the officer’s salary is very bold and will instil discipline. Only such action can curb arbitrariness in police stations.”
The press note says similar situations are seen in Maharashtra from time to time. When allegations of custodial violence or illegal arrest surface in the state, police often cite reasons such as CCTV being switched off, footage being destroyed or audio missing. The Bombay High Court has earlier reprimanded the state Home Department several times over the poor condition of CCTV systems in police stations. Although the Supreme Court’s directions require one year of data to be preserved and regular audits to be carried out, the press note says negligence in maintenance, despite funds being spent, has led to a serious lack of transparency in Maharashtra’s police stations as well.
Key points
- Four people were held illegally for 10 days at Gauri Bazar police station, Deoria.
- The Allahabad High Court ordered total compensation of ₹65,000.
- The full amount is to be recovered from the SHO’s salary.
- The court called the police a “bunch of liars” over the CCTV claim.
- The SP’s apology was rejected; he was told to apologise to the public.
- The court objected to the use of ₹46.46 lakh sanctioned for CCTV.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who will pay the compensation?
The court directed that the entire ₹65,000 be recovered from the salary of the SHO of Gauri Bazar police station.
What did the Supreme Court order on CCTV in police stations?
In the Paramvir Singh Saini case, the Supreme Court made CCTV cameras with night vision and audio-video recording mandatory in every police station, with one year of data to be preserved and regular audits carried out.
Read this story in Hindi: 10 दिन अवैध हिरासत पर हाईकोर्ट सख्त, थाना प्रभारी के वेतन से 65 हजार मुआवजा
सीधे अपनी Facebook फ़ीड में पाएँ — News Nation Online पेज को Follow करें।
Discover more from NewsNation Online
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

















Leave a Reply